If you’ve ever wanted to disappear to your own island — but still host 10 of your closest friends — this upstate New York property might be as close as it gets.
Tucked just yards from the Canadian border in Alexandria Bay, this 11-bedroom estate sits on its own private island in the Thousand Islands region — and it’s the kind of place where life slows down the second you step off the boat.
The home, listed at $4.2 million, spans more than 7,600 square feet and dates back to 1895. But don’t expect anything run-down or rustic. This is old-school craftsmanship done right — rich hardwood floors, detailed oak woodwork, and a layout built for both quiet mornings and full-on summer gatherings.
The kitchen leans into that classic, timeless feel, with mission-style cabinetry, a gas stove, and a butler’s pantry for when entertaining turns serious. Large windows frame the river from nearly every angle, making the outside feel like part of the home.
And then there’s the lifestyle.
Morning starts with coffee on a wraparound porch as boats drift by. Afternoons might mean jumping off the dock, taking the boat out, or just sitting under the trees watching the water. Evenings? That’s where the property really shows off.
An enclosed gazebo doubles as a full outdoor entertaining space, complete with a kitchen — ideal for long dinners, summer parties, or just stretching out the day as the sun sets over the river.
The dock is deep and protected, giving easy access to open water, which makes this place especially appealing for boaters. But even if you never leave the island, there’s more than enough here to keep you busy.
It’s private without feeling isolated. Peaceful without being boring.
To put it in perspective, the median home price in the Alexandria Bay area typically falls in the $200,000 to $300,000 range. That means this estate isn’t just above average — it’s in an entirely different category.
And yet, it didn’t always carry that kind of price tag. The property last sold in 2016 for $950,000 — a reminder of just how rare and valuable these kinds of waterfront estates have become.
Of course, owning a private island comes with trade-offs. You’re not running out for coffee. Amazon deliveries might be… complicated. And winter likely changes the rhythm entirely.
But that’s also the appeal.
This isn’t a starter home or even a typical luxury property. It’s a retreat. A summer hub. The kind of place where family traditions are built over decades, not weekends.
Click here to view the complete listing on Zillow.
