These Sauk County School Districts Received the Lowest Overall Grades

classroom A classroom. (Canva/Jason Doiy)

Three public school districts received the lowest overall grades on Niche’s 2027 Best School Districts list for Sauk County, Wisconsin, with grades ranging from C+ to B−.

One of the two B− districts earned an A− in Sports and a C in Food. The other earned a B+ in Clubs & Activities and a C+ in Sports. Both made the list because they shared the B− cutoff.

Under Niche’s 2027 district methodology, Academics accounts for half the overall grade and draws on factors including state test results, college enrollment and survey responses.

Niche also weighs factors such as its Teachers grade and parent and student feedback. Wisconsin issues its own ratings through the Department of Public Instruction’s school and district report cards.

School District of Reedsburg — Overall Niche Grade B−

Sports was Reedsburg’s strongest category at A−, while Food was its lowest at C on the district’s Niche report card. The district serves Reedsburg and surrounding communities, including La Valle, and Niche lists 2,591 students from prekindergarten through 12th grade.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsB−
DiversityB−
TeachersB
College PrepB
Clubs & ActivitiesB
AdministrationC+
SportsA−
FoodC
Resources & FacilitiesB−

Reading and math proficiency were two points apart

Niche’s figures from Wisconsin’s 2024–25 state assessments show 36% of tested students scored at or above proficiency in reading or English language arts and 34% did so in math. Niche identifies the testing year for those figures, which summarize performance across tested grades.

The district’s reported student-teacher ratio of 13:1 was below the National Center for Education Statistics’ 2023–24 public-school benchmark of 15.2:1. Niche gives no reporting year for the district ratio.

The measure divides enrollment by full-time-equivalent teachers across the district. Class size counts the students assigned to an individual classroom.

Construction and child development courses carry college credit

Reedsburg Area High School students can earn credit toward both high school and college through Madison College’s dual-credit partnership with Reedsburg. The college lists three-credit courses in construction fundamentals, child development and introductory college writing among the local options.

Students take the courses at their high school and need a C or better to earn credit from both institutions. Families planning next year’s schedule can ask the high school counselor which dual-credit classes will run and how students register for the college credit.

Sauk Prairie School District — Overall Niche Grade B−

Sauk Prairie earned a B+ in Clubs & Activities, its strongest category, and a C+ in College Prep on Niche’s district report card. The district serves Prairie du Sac, Sauk City and Merrimac, among other communities in its elementary attendance areas.

Niche lists 2,658 students from prekindergarten through 12th grade.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsB
DiversityC
TeachersB
College PrepC+
Clubs & ActivitiesB+
AdministrationC+
SportsC+
FoodB−
Resources & FacilitiesB−

Reading proficiency was six points above math

On the 2024–25 Wisconsin state assessments summarized by Niche, 44% of tested students scored at or above proficiency in reading or English language arts and 38% did so in math.

Niche displays a student-teacher ratio of 13:1, consistent with the rounded figure from the federal district directory’s 2024–25 staffing data. That was below the federal public-school benchmark of 15.2:1 from 2023–24.

Fourth and fifth graders share lessons in Merrimac

At Merrimac Community School, fourth and fifth graders sometimes learn together in science, social studies and other classes. The public charter elementary school serves 4K through fifth grade and uses projects that ask children to research a question or work through a problem connected to their community.

The district assigns children in the village and town of Merrimac to the school under its attendance boundaries, subject to placement needs. Families elsewhere in the district can check with the district office about attending outside their assigned area.

School District of Baraboo — Overall Niche Grade C+

Baraboo’s Niche report card shows its widest gap between College Prep, at B+, and Administration, at D+. The district serves Baraboo and nearby communities, including North Freedom, where it operates North Freedom Elementary School.

Niche lists 2,598 students from prekindergarten through 12th grade.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsB−
DiversityB−
TeachersC+
College PrepB+
Clubs & ActivitiesB−
AdministrationD+
SportsC+
FoodC
Resources & FacilitiesB−

About a third of tested students reached proficiency

Niche reports that 35% of tested students scored at or above proficiency in reading or English language arts and 31% did so in math on Wisconsin’s 2024–25 state assessments.

Baraboo’s student-teacher ratio was 12:1 on Niche, below the 2023–24 national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1. Niche gives no reporting year for Baraboo’s staffing figure.

Juniors and seniors can apply for paid apprenticeships

The Youth Apprenticeship elective at Baraboo High School combines classroom instruction with paid, supervised work for juniors and seniors. Students can participate for one year or across both grades, with priority for seniors.

The one-year option requires at least 450 hours of work.

Applicants must interview and secure a job with a participating employer. The school also reviews attendance and academic standing, so students interested in fitting an apprenticeship around required courses can start with the high school’s course planning process.

The overall grades were close. The category grades varied.

The cutoff fell at B−. The two other districts on the five-result list, River Valley and Wisconsin Dells, earned B and B+, respectively. That put the next district just one grade step above the cutoff.

Baraboo earned a higher College Prep grade than either of the two B− districts. Reedsburg and Sauk Prairie shared B grades for Teachers and B− grades for Resources & Facilities, while their Sports grades were three steps apart.

Sauk Prairie’s B+ in Clubs & Activities was a step above Reedsburg’s B.

The comparison covers the five districts on Niche’s list. Sauk County’s own directory identifies other districts serving local students, including Weston.

Families can start with Sauk County’s address-based school district finder, confirm the assigned school with the district, and then look up that school’s state report card.

For an apprenticeship, dual-credit course or a particular elementary program, check eligibility and enrollment with the school before building it into next year’s plans.