These Tuscarawas County School Districts Received the Lowest Overall Grades

classroom A classroom. (Canva/maroke)

Five public school districts received the lowest overall grades on Niche’s 2027 Best School Districts list for Tuscarawas County, Ohio, with grades ranging from C to B.

Three districts tied at B, the cutoff for the third-lowest spot, so all three are included. Even among those districts, the report cards differed. One earned an A− in Teachers and a C− in Resources & Facilities.

Under Niche’s 2027 district methodology, Academics accounts for half of the overall grade and draws on state test results, college enrollment and survey responses.

Niche also weighs factors such as its Teachers grade and feedback from parents and students. The state publishes its own evaluations through the Ohio School Report Cards.

Garaway Local School District — Overall Niche Grade B

Garaway earned A− grades in both Teachers and Food, while Clubs & Activities came in at C+ on Niche’s district report card. The district serves Sugarcreek and surrounding communities through schools that include campuses in Baltic, Dundee and Ragersville.

Niche lists 1,055 students in kindergarten through 12th grade.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsB+
DiversityC
TeachersA−
College PrepB−
Clubs & ActivitiesC+
AdministrationB
SportsB
FoodA−
Resources & FacilitiesB−

About three in four tested students reached proficiency

In Niche’s summary of Ohio’s 2024–25 state tests, 76% of tested Garaway students scored at or above proficiency in English language arts and 77% did so in math. The figures draw on state tests in grades 3–8 and high school end-of-course exams.

Niche displays 17 students per teacher, above the National Center for Education Statistics’ 2023–24 public-school benchmark of 15.2 students per teacher. The district figure has no year attached on Niche.

The ratio measures staffing across the district using full-time-equivalent teachers. Class size counts the students assigned to an individual classroom.

Band starts in fifth grade

The Garaway music department lists band for grades 5–12 and choir for grades 7–12. Younger students have general music, with the department posting a rotating elementary schedule for its four campuses.

Families interested in fifth-grade band can check with their elementary school about when students bring instruments and how rehearsals fit into the week.

Indian Valley Local School District — Overall Niche Grade B

Indian Valley earned an A− in Teachers and a B in Sports in Niche’s 2027 listings. Niche’s district profile lists 1,589 students in kindergarten through 12th grade. The district operates schools in Gnadenhutten, Midvale, Port Washington and Tuscarawas.

Niche categoryGrade
Academics2027 grade unverified
Diversity2027 grade unverified
TeachersA−
College Prep2027 grade unverified
Clubs & Activities2027 grade unverified
Administration2027 grade unverified
SportsB
Food2027 grade unverified
Resources & Facilities2027 grade unverified

English language arts and math were one point apart

Niche displays 72% proficiency in English language arts and 73% in math. Those are the shares of tested students who reached or exceeded proficiency on Ohio’s 2024–25 state assessments.

Niche’s 2027 teaching listing shows a district ratio of 17:1, above the 2023–24 national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1. Niche gives no year for the district ratio.

Gifted services include specialist instruction in grades four and five

Indian Valley describes whole-grade screening for superior cognitive ability in second and fifth grades through its gifted education program. Its services include direct instruction from a gifted intervention specialist in fourth and fifth grades and honors courses in grades 6–12.

Families can use the district’s gifted education page to review how students are identified and what services are available at their grade level.

New Philadelphia City School District — Overall Niche Grade B

New Philadelphia earned an A− in Teachers and a C− in Resources & Facilities, the widest category gap on its Niche report card. The district serves New Philadelphia, and the federal district directory records 2,826 students in 2024–25 and a grade span from prekindergarten through 12th grade.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsB
DiversityB
TeachersA−
College PrepB−
Clubs & ActivitiesB−
AdministrationB
SportsB
FoodB
Resources & FacilitiesC−

Nearly two-thirds of tested students reached proficiency

Niche’s summary of Ohio’s 2024–25 assessments shows 65% of tested students reached or exceeded proficiency in English language arts, and 63% did so in math.

Niche displays 18:1, consistent with the federal district directory’s 2024–25 ratio of 17.87 students per teacher before rounding. That was above the 2023–24 national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1.

High school students can design and test digital circuits

New Philadelphia High School’s career and technical education course descriptions list a Project Lead the Way Digital Electronics course. Students use computer simulations to design and test electronics.

The course has a prerequisite, so students interested in taking it can plan the sequence with a high school counselor.

Claymont City School District — Overall Niche Grade C+

Claymont earned a B+ in Teachers and a C in College Prep on Niche’s 2027 district report card. The district serves Dennison and Uhrichsville, the two communities that formed Claymont according to the district’s technology plan.

Niche lists 1,529 students from prekindergarten through 12th grade.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsC+
DiversityC−
TeachersB+
College PrepC
Clubs & ActivitiesB−
AdministrationC
SportsC
Food2027 grade unverified
Resources & Facilities2027 grade unverified

More than half of tested students reached proficiency in each subject

Niche’s 2024–25 Ohio test figures show 57% of tested Claymont students reached or exceeded proficiency in English language arts and 55% did so in math.

Claymont’s reported ratio of 17:1 was above the 2023–24 national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1. Niche gives no year for Claymont’s ratio.

Virtual Academy offers remote work and in-person lab days

Claymont’s 2026–27 academic planning guide describes a Virtual Academy for grades 7–12. Students can take coursework remotely or use in-person lab days for support.

The program provides a route to a Claymont High School diploma through Ohio’s Credit Flexibility pathway.

Newcomerstown Exempted Village School District — Overall Niche Grade C

Teachers was Newcomerstown’s highest category at B−, while College Prep and Administration both earned C− on Niche’s district report card.

The district serves Newcomerstown, and the federal district directory records 869 students in 2024–25 and a grade span from prekindergarten through 12th grade.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsC
DiversityC
TeachersB−
College PrepC−
Clubs & ActivitiesC
AdministrationC−
SportsC+
FoodC+
Resources & FacilitiesC+

English language arts proficiency was eight points above math

Among students tested on Ohio’s 2024–25 assessments, 59% reached or exceeded proficiency in English language arts and 51% did so in math, according to the figures Niche displays.

Niche shows a ratio of 14:1, consistent with the rounded 2024–25 federal district figure of 14.25 students per teacher. That was below the 2023–24 national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1.

STEM students take their work to a regional showcase

Students in Newcomerstown’s Project Lead the Way classes had a chance to present their work at the district’s April 2026 STEM showcase at Buckeye Career Center. The event gave families a place to see what students were doing in science, technology, engineering and math.

Families interested in the program can ask their school which Project Lead the Way classes are available for their child’s grade.

The B Tie Was One Grade Step Below the Rest of the List

The three districts at the cutoff earned B overall. Dover, Strasburg-Franklin and Tuscarawas Valley each earned B+, one step higher. Niche returned nine entries in all. Eight had verifiable overall grades, and the Buckeye Career Center district profile displayed no overall letter grade.

The category grades showed differences within the tie. Garaway and New Philadelphia shared a B− in College Prep, but Garaway earned an A− in Food while New Philadelphia earned a B.

Among the two districts below the cutoff, Newcomerstown earned a C+ in Sports, a step above Claymont’s C in Niche’s 2027 athletics listing.

For families checking a particular address, Ohio’s school district finder can identify the district. From there, confirm the assigned building with the district and check that school’s state results for the grade your child will enter.

Ask the school about prerequisites or placement if a program is part of the decision.