These Are The Worst School Districts in Hillsdale County, According to Niche

classroom Canva/Diana

Five public school districts in Hillsdale County, Michigan, received overall grades ranging from C+ to D+ in Niche’s latest individual evaluations, with three districts tied at C+ in the education review website’s 2027 Hillsdale County school district listing.

The report cards reveal some striking differences. One district earned an A− in Sports despite receiving a C+ overall, while another earned a B+ in Resources & Facilities despite receiving a D+ overall.

Niche’s school district ranking methodology considers factors including state test scores, college readiness, graduation rates, teacher quality and reviews. Its letter grades are independent evaluations, not official grades assigned by the Michigan Department of Education.

Jonesville Community Schools — Overall Niche Grade C+

Jonesville Community Schools earned a B+ in Teachers and a B− in Academics, but received C grades in Sports, Food, Clubs & Activities, and Resources & Facilities, according to its Niche district report card.

The district serves approximately 1,180 students in prekindergarten through 12th grade in Jonesville and surrounding communities.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsB−
DiversityC+
TeachersB+
College PrepC+
Clubs & ActivitiesC
AdministrationB
SportsC
FoodC
Resources & FacilitiesC

Reading and Math Proficiency Match at 36%

According to Niche, 36% of Jonesville students demonstrated proficiency in reading and 36% in mathematics.

The figures come from the Michigan Department of Education’s 2024–25 statewide testing program, including M-STEP assessments for grades 3–8 and the Michigan Merit Exam for grade 11.

Jonesville reports a student-teacher ratio of 18:1, above the national public-school ratio of 15.2:1 reported by the National Center for Education Statistics for 2023–24.

Niche does not identify the district staffing figure’s reporting year, making the national figure a historical benchmark rather than a same-year comparison. Student-teacher ratios describe districtwide staffing, not average class size.

Students Can Explore Skilled Trades Before Graduation

Jonesville High School offers career and technical education opportunities through regional training centers.

The school’s 2025–26 course catalog describes off-campus vocational courses available to qualified juniors and seniors with counselor approval.

Students can pursue training through the Hillsdale Area Career Center, including construction trades and other occupational programs.

The catalog also describes opportunities at the Jackson and Branch area career centers, although tuition requirements may differ.

Families interested in these pathways should speak with a high school counselor about prerequisites, transportation and program availability.

North Adams-Jerome Public Schools — Overall Niche Grade C+

North Adams-Jerome Public Schools received B+ grades in Teachers and Resources & Facilities, but its Academics, Diversity and Sports categories each earned a C.

The district’s Niche report card also shows B grades in Clubs & Activities and Administration.

Based in North Adams, the district serves approximately 301 students in prekindergarten through 12th grade, making it one of the smaller districts in the county listing.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsC
DiversityC
TeachersB+
College PrepB−
Clubs & ActivitiesB
AdministrationB
SportsC
FoodC+
Resources & FacilitiesB+

Reading Proficiency Falls Below Math

Niche reports 16% reading proficiency and 22% mathematics proficiency for North Adams-Jerome.

Those figures reflect the Michigan Department of Education’s 2024–25 statewide testing program, including M-STEP and Michigan Merit Exam results.

The district has a student-teacher ratio of 14:1, compared with the NCES national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1 for 2023–24.

Although the staffing figure is lower than the national benchmark, it does not establish how many students are assigned to individual classrooms or explain the district’s academic results.

Career Training Extends Beyond the District

North Adams-Jerome students can explore career and technical education through the Hillsdale Area Career Center.

The center’s official partner-school directory identifies North Adams-Jerome among the participating districts.

Programs at the center include construction trades, cybersecurity, criminal justice, health sciences, mechatronics and welding.

The training emphasizes hands-on learning, industry skills and career exploration. Some programs offer opportunities to earn credentials or college credit.

Students interested in participating should consult their school counselor about eligibility, transportation and scheduling.

Reading Community Schools — Overall Niche Grade C+

Reading Community Schools received an A− in Sports, its strongest category grade, while Academics earned a C+ and College Prep received a C.

The district’s Niche report card also assigns B grades in Teachers and Food and B− grades in Clubs & Activities, Administration, and Resources & Facilities.

Reading serves approximately 690 students in kindergarten through 12th grade in the Reading area of southern Hillsdale County.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsC+
DiversityC
TeachersB
College PrepC
Clubs & ActivitiesB−
AdministrationB−
SportsA−
FoodB
Resources & FacilitiesB−

Reading Scores Outpace Math

According to Niche, 36% of students demonstrated proficiency in reading, compared with 29% in mathematics.

The results come from Michigan’s 2024–25 statewide testing program, including M-STEP and the Michigan Merit Exam.

Reading reports a student-teacher ratio of 17:1, compared with the national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1 for 2023–24.

The district ratio’s reporting year is not identified on Niche’s report card.

Early Middle College Offers a Head Start

Reading Community Schools provides an Early Middle College pathway that allows participating students to accumulate college credits while completing high school.

According to the district’s 2024–25 financial report, the program allows students to complete a five-year high school pathway, with the final year primarily devoted to college coursework.

Students who successfully complete the program can graduate with up to 30 college credits.

The district also offers dual enrollment and opportunities to attend career centers.

For families weighing college costs, the program provides a way to begin postsecondary education before leaving high school. Students should verify admission requirements, credit transferability and the additional year of participation.

Pittsford Area Schools — Overall Niche Grade C

Pittsford Area Schools received a C overall, with C− grades in Academics and College Prep.

Its Niche report card shows stronger evaluations in Teachers and Sports, which both received B grades, and Resources & Facilities, which earned a B−.

The district serves approximately 366 students in kindergarten through 12th grade in Pittsford and surrounding communities.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsC−
DiversityC
TeachersB
College PrepC−
Clubs & ActivitiesC
AdministrationC+
SportsB
FoodC+
Resources & FacilitiesB−

Reading and Math Proficiency Both Stand at 11%

Pittsford’s report card shows 11% of students proficient in reading and 11% proficient in mathematics.

The percentages reflect Michigan’s 2024–25 statewide testing program, including grade 3–8 M-STEP assessments and the grade 11 Michigan Merit Exam.

The district reports a student-teacher ratio of 17:1, compared with the NCES national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1 for 2023–24.

The district ratio’s underlying reporting year is not specified.

Juniors and Seniors Can Pursue Technical Careers

Pittsford Area High School offers career and technical education through the Hillsdale Area Career Center.

The district’s high school student handbook describes opportunities in construction trades, criminal justice, cybersecurity, education, health sciences, mechatronics and welding.

The handbook states that juniors and seniors who have completed their ninth- and 10th-grade core curriculum can participate, subject to available seats.

Because the handbook is from 2022–23, families should confirm current requirements with the high school.

The center’s current program offerings continue to include several of those technical fields.

Litchfield Community Schools — Overall Niche Grade D+

Litchfield Community Schools received the lowest overall grade among the five districts, earning a D+.

However, its Niche report card shows considerably stronger evaluations in Resources & Facilities, which received a B+, and Food, which earned a B.

Academics received a D+, while Teachers, Diversity, Administration, Sports, and Clubs & Activities each received C grades. College Prep was not graded.

The district serves approximately 253 students in prekindergarten through 12th grade in Litchfield.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsD+
DiversityC
TeachersC
College PrepNot graded
Clubs & ActivitiesC
AdministrationC
SportsC
FoodB
Resources & FacilitiesB+

Reading and Math Proficiency Remain Below 20%

Niche reports that 17% of Litchfield students demonstrated proficiency in reading, while 12% demonstrated proficiency in mathematics.

The results are attributed to Michigan’s 2024–25 statewide testing program, including M-STEP and Michigan Merit Exam assessments.

Litchfield reports a student-teacher ratio of 20:1, above the NCES national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1 for 2023–24.

Niche does not identify the reporting year for the district staffing ratio.

The district’s relatively high student-teacher ratio is a staffing measure and should not be interpreted as an average classroom enrollment figure.

Career Programs Provide Additional Options

Litchfield Community Schools participates in the Hillsdale Area Career Center’s regional technical education network.

The center’s official program information identifies Litchfield as a partner district and describes training in fields including cybersecurity, health sciences, construction and welding.

Programs emphasize practical instruction and work-readiness skills, with some offering opportunities to earn industry-recognized credentials or college credits.

Families can contact the school district or career center to learn which programs are available to Litchfield students and how participation fits into the regular high school schedule.

What the Hillsdale County Grades Reveal

The five report cards show that overall grades do not always reflect the strongest individual programs or services within a district.

Reading Community Schools received an A− in Sports, while North Adams-Jerome and Jonesville earned B+ grades in Teachers.

Litchfield, despite receiving the lowest overall grade of the group, matched North Adams-Jerome’s B+ in Resources & Facilities.

The differences are also apparent in academic results. The published reading proficiency figures range from 11% at Pittsford to 36% at Jonesville and Reading, while mathematics proficiency ranges from 11% at Pittsford to 36% at Jonesville.

Those figures describe the percentages reported on Niche’s district profiles, not necessarily identical tested populations.

The 2027 county listing includes six districts. Three of the featured districts received C+ grades, placing them at the cutoff for a three-district selection and requiring all three to be included under the tie rule.

The listing currently displays Hillsdale Community Schools at C+, although its individual report card displays B−. That inconsistency prevents a fully reconciled countywide comparison.

For families, districtwide letter grades are only a starting point.

Parents can review school-level academic results through Michigan’s official MI School Data portal and contact school counselors about college credit, career training and academic support programs.

The most useful comparison may be the one involving the specific school, grade level and educational opportunities their child will actually experience.