A nearly century-old Craftsman tucked into one of Bainbridge Island’s most sought-after neighborhoods just hit the market for $1.098 million — offering a glimpse at what seven figures buys in today’s Kitsap County housing market.
The 1932 home pairs old-school charm with updated interiors, all set on a lush one-acre property in the quiet West Port Madison area.
Quick Snapshot
- Price: $1,098,000
- Location: Bainbridge Island, Kitsap County
- Beds/Baths: 3 beds, 2 baths
- Square Footage: 2,208 square feet
- Lot Size: 1 acre
- Built: 1932
- Standout Feature: Classic Craftsman charm paired with a separate finished bonus space above the garage
First Impression
The home immediately leans into the kind of Pacific Northwest atmosphere buyers dream about when they picture Bainbridge Island.
Listing details from COMPASS show the two-story Craftsman surrounded by dense greenery and mature landscaping, giving the property a tucked-away, almost storybook feel despite being relatively close to Seattle ferry access.
The covered front porch does a lot of heavy lifting here. It stretches across the front of the house and looks built for slow mornings, coffee mugs, and rainy-day conversations while overlooking the property’s lush surroundings.
Inside The Home
Inside, the home keeps much of its vintage personality intact without feeling frozen in time. Warm hardwood floors run throughout much of the house, while custom built-ins with glass-paneled doors frame a wood-burning fireplace in the living room.
The kitchen feels clean and functional rather than flashy. Stainless steel appliances and simple lines modernize the space, while a cozy breakfast nook with built-in bench seating adds some of the home’s strongest personality.
The main-level primary suite gives the floor plan a more practical feel for long-term living.
Upstairs spaces continue the home’s softer, classic aesthetic with sloped ceilings, warm light, and understated finishes instead of ultra-modern luxury trends.
The Charm Factor
This isn’t a mega-mansion kind of million-dollar listing. The appeal here is more about land, privacy, character, and Bainbridge lifestyle than flashy excess.
Still, a few standout details help explain the seven-figure price tag:
- One-acre property in West Port Madison
- Detached finished bonus space above garage
- Covered Craftsman-style front porch
- Wood-burning fireplace with built-in cabinetry
- Main-floor primary suite
- Mature landscaping and privacy
- Dedicated breakfast nook with built-in seating
The Big Picture
For context, median home prices in Kitsap County hover between $525K and $577K, but Bainbridge Island operates in a different lane than much of the county thanks to its Seattle commuter appeal, limited inventory, waterfront access, and reputation for quiet luxury living.
The home last sold in 1996 for $165,000. Its 2024 property tax bill came in at roughly $6,800.
Now listed for just over $1 million, the property reflects both decades of regional appreciation and the continued demand for homes that offer character, land, and proximity to Seattle.
Final Take
This listing probably won’t spark the same internet shock as a futuristic mega-mansion or waterfront compound. Instead, it taps into something quieter — the kind of Pacific Northwest home many buyers actually picture themselves living in.
