These Are The Worst School Districts in Defiance County, According to Niche

classroom A classroom. (Canva/FatCamera)

Four public school districts in Defiance County, Ohio, received overall B or B+ grades on their individual Niche report cards, placing them in the lowest grade group when compared with the education review website’s 2027 Best School Districts in Defiance County listing.

The results reveal some notable contrasts. One district received an A+ for Food but a C for Sports. Another earned an A− in Sports while receiving C grades in Food and Resources & Facilities.

Two districts received B grades and two received B+ grades, creating a tie at the cutoff that expands the selection to four.

Niche’s school district evaluation methodology incorporates academic performance, college readiness, graduation rates, teacher-related measures and student and parent reviews.

Its grades are independent evaluations and should not be confused with the official report cards issued by the Ohio Department of Education and Workforce.

Central Local School District — Overall Niche Grade B+

Central Local School District earned an A in Teachers and A− grades in Academics and Administration, but its Food and Diversity categories received C+ grades.

According to the district’s Niche report card, Clubs & Activities and Sports each received B+ grades, while College Prep and Resources & Facilities earned B− grades.

Based in Sherwood, the district serves approximately 882 students in kindergarten through 12th grade, including students attending Fairview schools.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsA−
DiversityC+
TeachersA
College PrepB−
Clubs & ActivitiesB+
AdministrationA−
SportsB+
FoodC+
Resources & FacilitiesB−

Reading and Math Proficiency Both Exceed 70%

Niche reports that 75% of Central Local students are proficient in reading and 74% are proficient in mathematics.

Those percentages represent the share of students scoring at or above proficiency on state reading/language arts and mathematics assessments, as displayed by Niche.

The assessment year is not identified on the accessible report card, so the figures should not be interpreted as current-year results or evidence of a trend.

The district reports a student-teacher ratio of 15:1, compared with the national public-school ratio of 15.2:1 reported by the National Center for Education Statistics for 2023–24.

Niche does not identify the reporting year for the district staffing figure. The national figure is therefore a historical benchmark, not a confirmed same-year comparison. Student-teacher ratios measure districtwide staffing rather than average class size.

Career Training Connects Students With Four County Programs

Fairview High School students have access to regional career and technical education through Four County Career Center.

The district’s high school information page specifically references students attending Four County and includes administrative information for families whose children participate.

The center provides a vocational pathway alongside traditional high school coursework, allowing eligible students to explore technical careers before graduation.

Families should contact Fairview High School’s counseling office about current program choices, application deadlines, transportation and how career-center coursework fits graduation requirements.

Northeastern Local School District (Defiance) — Overall Niche Grade B+

Northeastern Local School District received A grades in Teachers and A− grades in Sports and Food, but a C in Diversity and B− in Resources & Facilities.

Its Niche report card also shows B+ grades in Academics, Clubs & Activities and Administration.

The district operates Tinora Elementary, Tinora Middle and Tinora High schools, serving approximately 940 students in kindergarten through 12th grade in the Defiance area.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsB+
DiversityC
TeachersA
College PrepB
Clubs & ActivitiesB+
AdministrationB+
SportsA−
FoodA−
Resources & FacilitiesB−

Three in Four Students Meet Reading Proficiency

Niche reports 75% reading proficiency and 69% mathematics proficiency in Northeastern Local School District.

The percentages measure students scoring at or above the proficiency level on Ohio’s state assessments. Niche does not identify the assessment year in the accessible report card, so the results should be treated as displayed figures rather than current-year measurements.

Northeastern reports a student-teacher ratio of 19:1, above the national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1 from NCES for 2023–24.

The district staffing ratio’s reporting year is not identified, and the figure does not measure average class size.

Agricultural Education and Fine Arts Offer Specialized Experiences

Tinora High School provides students with extracurricular and educational opportunities extending beyond conventional classroom instruction.

The district’s official high school information and program directory identifies Future Farmers of America (FFA), a Fine Arts Department and a performing arts center among its offerings.

FFA provides an avenue for students interested in agricultural education and leadership activities. Fine arts opportunities allow students to participate in creative work and performances through the high school.

Families interested in those activities can contact Tinora High School about course offerings, membership requirements and opportunities to participate during the school year.

Defiance City School District — Overall Niche Grade B

Defiance City School District received an A− in Sports and Diversity, but C grades in Food and Resources & Facilities.

The district’s Niche report card also assigns B+ grades in Teachers and Administration, while Academics and College Prep each received B−.

Defiance City serves approximately 2,344 students in kindergarten through 12th grade, making it the largest district included in the county listing.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsB−
DiversityA−
TeachersB+
College PrepB−
Clubs & ActivitiesB
AdministrationB+
SportsA−
FoodC
Resources & FacilitiesC

Math Proficiency Slightly Exceeds Reading

According to Niche, 60% of Defiance City students are proficient in mathematics, compared with 59% in reading.

The figures reflect the percentages displayed by Niche for state assessment proficiency. Their underlying assessment year was not established from the report card.

The district reports a student-teacher ratio of 16:1, slightly above the NCES national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1 for 2023–24.

Because Niche does not identify the year of its district staffing figure, the comparison should not be interpreted as a same-year measure.

Students Can Earn College Credits in High School

Defiance High School offers College Credit Plus, an Ohio program that allows eligible students to earn high school and college credit through qualifying college-level courses.

According to the school’s 2024–25 student handbook, participating students must meet college admission requirements and receive counselor approval.

The handbook also describes Advanced Placement courses and a Credit Flexibility option, which allows eligible students to earn credit by demonstrating competency rather than relying exclusively on traditional classroom instruction.

Families should verify current deadlines and requirements with the counseling office, particularly because the handbook describes an earlier school year.

Hicksville Exempted Village School District — Overall Niche Grade B

Hicksville Exempted Village School District received an A+ in Food and an A− in Academics, but earned a C in Sports and a C+ in College Prep.

The district’s Niche report card also shows a B+ in Teachers and Resources & Facilities.

Located in Hicksville, the district serves approximately 868 students in kindergarten through 12th grade.

Niche categoryGrade
AcademicsA−
DiversityC+
TeachersB+
College PrepC+
Clubs & ActivitiesB
AdministrationB−
SportsC
FoodA+
Resources & FacilitiesB+

Math Proficiency Reaches 89%

Hicksville has the highest mathematics proficiency percentage displayed among the four featured district report cards.

Niche reports 89% mathematics proficiency and 79% reading proficiency, measuring the percentages of students scoring at or above proficiency on state assessments.

The underlying assessment year is not identified on the accessible report card. The figures therefore should not be characterized as results from the current school year.

Hicksville reports a student-teacher ratio of 13:1, below the NCES national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1 for 2023–24.

The district staffing ratio’s reporting year is unspecified, and the ratio does not represent average classroom size.

College Credit Plus Provides an Early Start

Hicksville offers College Credit Plus opportunities for students interested in completing college-level coursework before graduating from high school.

The district maintains an official College Credit Plus information page and includes the program among its middle and high school resources.

Eligible students can potentially earn college credit while satisfying high school requirements, subject to the state’s program rules and college admission standards.

The district also provides information about graduation pathways, course scheduling and high school academic planning.

Families should contact Hicksville’s counseling department about current eligibility, participating colleges, deadlines and how credits will transfer.

What the Defiance County Report Cards Reveal

The district report cards show that overall grades do not necessarily follow individual academic or staffing measures.

Hicksville, for example, received an A− in Academics and reported 89% mathematics proficiency, despite receiving a B overall. Northeastern received a B+ overall and earned an A in Teachers, while Central Local also received an A in Teachers.

Defiance City earned the strongest Diversity grade among the featured districts at A−, while Hicksville received the strongest Food grade at A+.

Staffing figures also varied. Hicksville reported 13 students per teacher, compared with 19 at Northeastern. Those differences do not, by themselves, establish differences in instructional quality.

The cutoff for this comparison falls at B+, with Central Local and Northeastern tied at that grade. Defiance City and Hicksville each received B grades.

One inconsistency remains in Niche’s 2027 county listing: Ayersville appears with a B+ overall, while its individual report card displays A−. Using the individual grades produces the four-district selection presented here.

The discrepancy must be resolved before describing the selection as definitively countywide.

For families evaluating their educational options, the Ohio Department of Education and Workforce’s School Report Cards provide another way to examine academic achievement, graduation measures and other state-reported information.

Parents can also contact individual schools about college-credit eligibility, career and technical education, extracurricular programs and academic support services.

A districtwide letter grade provides a starting point, but the most relevant information may be what is happening in the particular school and grade a child attends.