Three public school districts in Columbia County, Wisconsin, received overall grades ranging from C+ to B− in Niche’s 2027 evaluations, based on the district report cards associated with its Best School Districts in Columbia County listing.
The report cards reveal some striking contrasts. One district earned an A− in Sports despite receiving the lowest overall grade in the group. Another received an A− for Teachers but a C− for College Prep. Two districts shared the B− cutoff grade.
Niche’s school district evaluation methodology considers academic performance, teacher-related measures, college readiness and student experiences. Its evaluations combine government data with surveys and reviews, making them different from the accountability report cards issued by the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction.
Here’s a closer look at the three districts, their academic results, staffing figures and educational opportunities.
Cambria-Friesland School District — Overall Niche Grade B−
An A− for Teachers was the strongest category grade on the Cambria-Friesland School District’s Niche report card. College Prep received a C−, creating a substantial contrast within the district’s evaluation.
Serving approximately 328 students in prekindergarten through 12th grade, the district operates schools in Cambria and serves the surrounding Cambria-Friesland community.
| Niche category | Grade |
|---|---|
| Academics | C+ |
| Diversity | B |
| Teachers | A− |
| College Prep | C− |
| Clubs & Activities | B− |
| Administration | B− |
| Sports | C+ |
| Food | B+ |
| Resources & Facilities | B+ |
The district also received B+ grades for Food and Resources & Facilities. Sports earned a C+, matching its Academics grade.
Reading proficiency exceeded math by seven points
According to Niche’s figures drawn from Wisconsin’s 2024–25 statewide testing program, 45% of tested students were proficient in reading or English language arts, compared with 38% in mathematics.
The figures represent students meeting or exceeding proficiency standards on applicable state assessments, including the Forward Exam and high school assessments. They do not represent the percentage of all enrolled students who passed a particular class.
Cambria-Friesland reported a student-teacher ratio of 11:1, compared with the national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1 reported by the National Center for Education Statistics for the 2023–24 school year.
The district ratio is a staffing measure, not an indication that every classroom contains 11 students.
College-credit opportunities extend beyond high school
Despite its C− College Prep grade, Cambria-Friesland has documented opportunities for students to earn college credit while attending high school.
The district’s published course materials describe high school classes that can carry college credit, along with Wisconsin’s Early College Credit Program and Start College Now program.
The latter programs provide routes for eligible students to pursue coursework through universities and technical colleges.
Families interested in those opportunities should contact the high school counselor about available classes, eligibility, application deadlines and any potential costs.
Portage Community School District — Overall Niche Grade B−
The Portage Community School District’s Niche report card gave Teachers a B+ and Administration a C−, the widest category-grade contrast in its evaluation.
The district serves approximately 1,975 students in prekindergarten through 12th grade, operating elementary, middle and high school programs in Portage and surrounding areas.
| Niche category | Grade |
|---|---|
| Academics | B− |
| Diversity | C+ |
| Teachers | B+ |
| College Prep | B |
| Clubs & Activities | B |
| Administration | C− |
| Sports | B |
| Food | B− |
| Resources & Facilities | B |
Five categories received grades of B or higher, including College Prep, Clubs & Activities, Sports and Resources & Facilities.
The Administration grade stood out as the lowest category result, although Niche’s overall evaluation does not establish what caused that difference.
Math proficiency was below reading proficiency
Niche reports that 36% of tested students were proficient in reading or English language arts, while 31% were proficient in mathematics.
The figures come from Wisconsin’s 2024–25 statewide testing program, as presented by Niche. The five-percentage-point difference describes the reported proficiency rates for the two subjects, not a change in performance over time.
The district reported a 13:1 student-teacher ratio.
That was below the NCES national public-school benchmark of 15.2:1 for 2023–24, although the district’s displayed staffing figure does not identify a matching reporting year.
A lower districtwide student-teacher ratio does not necessarily mean smaller individual classes.
Advanced coursework and gifted programming
Portage’s Niche district profile identifies Advanced Placement offerings and gifted programming among its educational opportunities.
Advanced Placement courses provide participating high school students with college-level academic work, while gifted services are intended to support students with advanced learning needs.
Families should consult the Portage Community School District for current course offerings, student eligibility and the schools or grade levels where particular services are available.
Those details matter because the availability of a program somewhere in a district does not mean every student has access to it at every grade level.
Pardeeville Area School District — Overall Niche Grade C+
The Pardeeville Area School District’s Niche report card showed an A− in Sports and a B+ in Clubs & Activities, even as the district received an overall C+.
Serving approximately 863 students in prekindergarten through 12th grade, the district operates elementary, middle and high school programs in Pardeeville.
| Niche category | Grade |
|---|---|
| Academics | B− |
| Diversity | C− |
| Teachers | B |
| College Prep | B− |
| Clubs & Activities | B+ |
| Administration | C+ |
| Sports | A− |
| Food | B− |
| Resources & Facilities | B |
Sports was the district’s highest-graded category, followed by Clubs & Activities.
Teachers and Resources & Facilities each received a B, while Academics and College Prep received B− grades.
Reading proficiency reached 41%
According to Niche’s presentation of Wisconsin’s 2024–25 assessment results, 41% of tested students were proficient in reading or English language arts, while 38% were proficient in mathematics.
The three-percentage-point difference was smaller than the gaps reported for the other two featured districts.
Pardeeville reported a 14:1 student-teacher ratio, compared with the NCES national benchmark of 15.2:1 for the 2023–24 school year.
As with the other districts, the ratio reflects districtwide staffing rather than the average number of students assigned to a classroom.
Career training and college-credit options
Pardeeville’s educational offerings extend beyond traditional academic courses.
District materials published through the Wisconsin Association of School Boards describe Advanced Placement and dual-credit coursework, along with career and technical education opportunities in agriculture, healthcare, business, apprenticeships and technology education.
Those programs can help participating high school students explore potential careers, develop occupational skills or earn credit toward further education.
The district’s published materials also describe extracurricular opportunities including FFA, SkillsUSA, Future Business Leaders of America and other student organizations.
Families should check with Pardeeville High School about current course availability, prerequisites and participation requirements.
What Columbia County’s District Report Cards Show
The three featured districts illustrate why an overall Niche grade should not be treated as a complete description of a school system.
Cambria-Friesland and Portage both received B− overall grades, but their category results differed substantially.
Cambria-Friesland received an A− in Teachers and a C− in College Prep. Portage earned a B+ in Teachers and a B in College Prep, while its Administration grade was C−.
Pardeeville, meanwhile, received the lowest overall grade of the three at C+, despite earning an A− for Sports and a B+ for Clubs & Activities.
The academic proficiency figures also tell a more detailed story. Reading proficiency ranged from 36% to 45% across the featured districts, while mathematics proficiency ranged from 31% to 38%.
Those results describe specific tested populations and assessments, rather than every student’s academic experience.
The districts’ reported student-teacher ratios ranged from 11:1 to 14:1, all below the 2023–24 national public-school benchmark.
The featured districts were selected using their overall Niche letter grades, not individual academic categories, enrollment, staffing ratios or numerical ranking positions.
For parents comparing schools, the report cards are a starting point. Families can also review the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction’s school and district report cards and contact their assigned schools about academic support, course offerings and opportunities available at specific grade levels.
